The woman who will get the part has a surgically enhanced body

Suppose that Glossie sees that if she's justified in believing C, she is also justified in believing D and thereby forms the belief D. However, unknown to Glossie, Barbie will be given the part. Also unknown to Glossie is the fact that Barbie has also had her body surgically enhanced to meet Hollywood's exacting standards. Thus D is true, but C from which, following rules of entailment, she inferred D, is false. Once again, all the conditions for knowledge according to the tripartite account are met:

0 0

Post a comment